Site Loader

Reading Recs

23 Mystery Books That Will Keep You Guessing

There’s nothing like the adrenaline rush of reading a mystery book, and we’re here to tell you about 22 that will absolutely stump you. Read on for our list of favorite YA mysteries that are ANYTHING but elementary, my dear Watson.

The Counselors
 by Jessica Goodman

Clue you’ll love it: three best friends, one elite summer camp, and the dark secrets that lead to a body in the lake. How could you resist?!

House of Hollow by Krystal Sutherland

Clue you’ll love it: Not only will you fall in love with every one of the Hollow sisters, but the answer to “Where did Grey Hollow go?” will haunt your nightmares for the rest of time.

They’ll Never Catch Us by Jessica Goodman 

Clue you’ll love it: Dangerously competitive sisters, and a new star athlete in town that suddenly goes missing? Yup. You will love the twisty unfolding mystery around the Steckler sisters, and what they might do to stay on top.

The Companion by Katie Alender

Clue you’ll love it: The other orphans say Margot is lucky. Lucky to survive the horrible accident that killed her family. Lucky to have her own room because she wakes up screaming every night. And finally, lucky to be chosen by a prestigious family to live at their remote country estate…until she meets Agatha.

The Beautiful by Renée Ahdieh

Clue you’ll love it: Not only will you be enthralled by the murder mystery set in New Orleans, but you won’t be able to resist the swoony paranormal romance. Welcome to the Court of Lions!

You’re So Dead by Ash Parsons

Clue you’ll love it: It’s hard to go wrong with a book about three friends who sneak themselves into an influencer festival on an island with a SERIAL KILLER on the loose.

The Taking of Jake Livingston by Ryan Douglass

Clue you’ll love it: Get Out meets Holly Jackson in this heart-stopping thriller where survival is not a guarantee.

Harrow Lake by Kat Ellis

Clue you’ll love it: it’s about the daughter of a horror film director who’s not afraid of anything…until she gets to Harrow Lake, where he filmed his most notorious slasher film. This town is not alright.

The Woods Are Always Watching by Stephanie Perkins 

Clue you’ll love it: The author of There’s Someone Inside Your House is back with a heart-stopping, gut-wrenching novel about friendship, survival, and navigating unmarked paths even as evil watches from the shadows.

Dark and Shallow Lies by Ginny Myers Sain 

Clue you’ll love it: Everyone is talking about how incredibly intense the last few pages are, and once you pick it up and meet the Summer Children…you’ll know why. Something VERY strange is happening in La Cachette.

The Girls Are Never Gone by Sarah Glenn Marsh 

Clue you’ll love it: The Conjuring meets Sadie when seventeen-year-old podcaster Dare takes an internship in a haunted house and finds herself in a life-or-death struggle against an evil spirit.

The Corpse Queen by Heather M. Herrman 

Clue you’ll love it: In this dark and twisty feminist historical mystery, a teenage girl starts a new life as a grave robber but quickly becomes entangled in a murderer’s plans.

People Like Us by Dana Mele

Clue you’ll love it: At Bates Academy, the truth is something you make…not something that happened. And after Kay finds herself is in the crosshairs of a murder investigation, she’ll do what it takes to survive.

Rules for Vanishing by Kate Alice Marshall 

Clue you’ll love it: It’s terrifying and eerie and oddly reminiscent of The Blair Witch Project. We may not recommend strolling down roads in the dead of night that only exist one day a year, but boy are they fun to read about.

They Wish They Were Us by Jessica Goodman 

Clue you’ll love it: This addictive mystery about the Players, an elite group at Gold Coast prep school, and the dark secrets they’re hiding just under the surface will have you guessing until the VERY last page.

Four Dead Queens by Astrid Scholte

Clue you’ll love it: The plot twist is so shocking even the author didn’t see it coming!

The Accident Season by Moïra Fowley-Doyle

Clue you’ll love it: supernatural + high stakes + one big question: is the fact that Cara’s family becomes inexplicably accident-prone every October is a coincidence…or a curse?

The Smaller Evil by Stephanie Kuehn

Clue you’ll love it: when Arman becomes the witness to something he can’t define at a self-help retreat, he’ll have to rely on the person he’s always trusted the least: himself.

Coming soon…

Go Hunt Me by Kelly deVos – Coming June 24, 2022!

Clue you’ll love it: this book follows seven horror buffs as their dream trip to a remote Romanian castle turns into a nightmare when they begin to be killed one by one. Need we say more?!

Who We Were in the Dark by Jessica Taylor – July 5, 2022!

Clue you’ll love it:How do you find someone you never really knew? Grace is missing. And Nora must find her way through the unspoken hurts and betrayals of the last two years to figure out what exactly happened to Grace, the girl she thought she knew.

These Fleeting Shadows by Kate Alice Marshall – Coming August 9, 2022!

Clue you’ll love it: The Haunting of Hill House meets Knives Out in a bid for an inheritance that will leave Helen Vaughan either rich…or dead.

How to Survive Your Murder by Danielle Valentine – Coming August 30, 2022!

Clue you’ll love it:Scream meets Happy Death Day. Get ready to relive one terrifying Halloween night over again as Alice races to find her sister’s killer before the clock strikes midnight!

Secrets So Deep by Ginny Myers Sain – Coming September 27, 2022!

Clue you’ll love it: mystery + theatre camp + lost memories.

Penguin Teen